Over the last two years, and even before then, Spanish midfielder Ander Herrera has shown himself to be one of the brightest young talents in La Liga, firstly with Zaragoza then with his hometown club, Athletic Bilbao. He’s caught the eye after his successes with Bilbao, finishing as runner-up in the 2011-12 Europa League and in the Copa del Rey in the same season. Plus he’s Spanish, so he must be good.
For me, the first time I noticed Herrera making a big impact was in the 2011 under-21 European Championships, where the Spaniard scored two goals as his country won the tournament. He excelled in a side that also contained the likes of now-Chelsea midfielder Juan Mata and David De Gea, who signed for Manchester United shortly after the tournament’s completion.
However, Herrera had already completed a move to one of the big clubs months in advance – Athletic Bilbao, his hometown club. Whilst they may not be one of the big players in Spanish football (that honour remains with Barcelona and Real Madrid), I still think this move was one of the best possible ones he could have made. If he had gone to one of the big two, or even abroad to a team like Chelsea, he probably wouldn’t have played anywhere near the same amount of games as he has done over the past two years, and his development would have suffered as a cause of that.
It’s fair to say that very few expected Ander Herrera to move in this transfer window which has just gone. He’s a very good player, but he’s got it good in Bilbao, and there’s very few clubs that could have tempted Herrera away from his city of birth. However, on 30th August 2013, Manchester United tried their hand at attempting to bring the 24-year-old to Old Trafford.
It’s fair to say that the summer has been a far from successful one for the Red Devils. Just one signing before deadline day (Guillermo Varela from Peñarol) and then two on it (Marouane Fellaini from Everton and Saidy Jango, a youngster from FC Zurich) left the United fans in a rage as attempts to sign a string of players failed throughout the summer months. Deals for Thiago Alcantara, Cesc Fabregas and Daniele de Rossi all fell through during the transfer window, and as the end of the window approached, Reds’ fans started to get more and more annoyed.
Ander Herrera, it seems, was a last-ditch attempt by United to bring in a central midfielder along with Fellaini. Although Herrera is very good, there are much better players whom United have pursued in this window that would improve the side more than the Bilbao-born man would. After an initial £21m offer for the player was rejected by his club in late August, it did seem that the venture was over, but that ended up not being the case.
I was as shocked as many last Friday when it was confirmed United’s offer has been rebuffed by the Basque club, as I believed that to be a fee worthy of Herrera. There was also talk that United could go back in for the former Zaragoza man, but journalists claimed that Herrera would not try to force the deal through, meaning Manchester United would have to pay the full €36m fee in order to get their target.
There were no developments in the story up until ‘Deadline Day Eve’, when it was rumoured once again that United would go all-out to try and sign the player on the final day of the transfer window, as they looked to strengthen their midfield, and sign the central midfield maestro that the fans have been craving for years now. These rumours started to gather pace on deadline day itself, along with ones linking Belgian Marouane Fellaini with a move to Old Trafford, which had been protracted for some while beforehand.
Then, there was a breakthrough. Guillem Balague, a Spanish reporter for Sky Sports and Spanish outlet AS revealed in his slot on Sky Sports News on deadline day that Manchester United were willing to pay the €36m fee to sign Herrera from Athletic. Some sources did claim that Balague can be unreliable at best, but excitement started to build as it seemed United were close to bringing in a very good young talent.
Whilst everyone was getting all excited over that bit of news, which may or may not have been true, reports came through that representatives of Manchester United had travelled to the LFP headquarters in Spain, in order to pay the money to activate Herrera’s release clause. These rumours continued to spread, but so did the worried looks on the faces of Manchester United fans as the end of deadline day came ever closer.
Even with the doubt, many still expected the Red Devils to seal the deal for the Spaniard before the window closed, so it came as a huge shock to many that United had failed in their bid, and were suffering ‘bureaucratic problems’ in regards to the deal, which meant the deal might not have gone through. The United representatives were even seen leaving LFP HQ, meaning that could have been an admission of defeat in the matter, leaving Herrera in Spain, and the United fans continually annoyed.
Now though, it seems those ‘representatives of Manchester United’ were not even that. Whilst they may not have been fakes, they didn’t represent United. They were in fact the same lawyers who helped Javi Martinez’s transfer from Athletic Bilbao to Bayern Munich go through last summer. They knew that a deal was ongoing between Bilbao and United at that moment, and were merely trying to get a cut of the money supposedly being exchanged. However, they certainly fooled many of the world’s top media outlets, probably without even knowing it.
It now appears that the real reason United pulled out of the deal to sign Herrera was due to an unwillingness to pay an extra €6m in tax add-ons, and as they couldn’t force Bilbao to negotiate with the LFP, they had no choice but to pull out of the deal, leaving Herrera and a lot of United fans annoyed. The blow was softened slightly by the confirmation that Belgium international Marouane Fellaini had joined the club a couple of hours later, but United’s supporters were still left very disappointed with how the Herrera deal ended, and United’s summer dealings on a whole, and some have even started calling for Ed Woodward’s (the chief executive at United) head after a disappointing window for the club.
Personally, I feel a bit sorry for Herrera that his move had to end in this way. It’s rumoured that he was very interested in the move, and was even willing to take a €2m per year pay-cut to move to Manchester, but he was prevented from completing his dream move by an unwillingness on United’s part to pay an extra few million to complete the deal. This could be exactly the type of move Herrera needs to develop his career further, and it’s been scuppered.
There have been whispers that United could go back in for Herrera in January after missing out on him in the summer window, and I think this will be the case. Whether or not he will still want to join the Red Devils after this saga remains to be seen though. Personally, I don’t think I’d still have an affinity for a club that neglected to part with an extra few million to sign me – then again, I’m not a footballer. Herrera will certainly have been disappointed at the way his move collapsed, but there’s still plenty of time left in his career to make a move to a club of Manchester United’s stature.